Board Thread:Suggestions/@comment-5486221-20160815070330/@comment-6883075-20160819125741

I don't think there's a problem with new users voting on all of the suggestions, just this one in particular. 90% of you just can't provide eligible reasons for not/do wanting Sif back. "I want to meet this guy..." isn't a eligible reason. Starting off your reason with "I've heard stories about this guy..." automatically makes it not an eligible reason. All you guys have heard about him is biased stories from a while ago and you can't provide a fair opinion of your own.

Most other suggestions actually will heavily effect the newer users, though, which is why I don't think there should normally be a citizenship policy on suggestions.