Board Thread:General Wiki Discussion/@comment-4969948-20160715192923/@comment-6883075-20160716195456

Yoponot wrote: Tabby had 25 edits and thus was let in. That's how it works. Tabby tried to come in without any edits back in November and she was kicked and blocked for it. No one let her slip in, Or ingored it, etc like you claim Rob.

Also how is it ok to be defensive about John. Sometimes you have to put your personal feelings aside to follow the rules.

Also the admins had a discussion last night and we worked all of our issues out. This thread isn't about our issues though, it's about if Toon should be demoted for the reasons listed above. Yopo, it's your job to know your wikis rules, and clearly you don't know them well enough. The rule has always been 15 mainspace edits before chat, one of the reasons you guys got upset at Johnny in the first place, and yes, I did point it out, and you did ignore it out of ignorance because she had 25 edits.

Yes, part of the job is to put aside personal relations and beliefs, but sometimes it doesn't work like that and it's okay to disagree with other admins' decisions. Maybe directly disobeying Mig rather than trying to talk it out was a bad idea on Toon's part, but whatever, he slipped up.

And I retain my comment; this thread is totally unfair to Toon. Most of the votes are still in support of CaT rather than against Toon. As I said, and now repeat, you should've made this two seperate votes, as now it's either "Get rid of Toon so we can have CaT" or "Keep Toon and don't get CaT". It's unfair to both parties.