Thread:ChromastoneandTabby/@comment-3441048-20161201045442/@comment-1824169-20161201054754

Thanks for the suggestions, but I think you might be missing the point a bit. The badges don't have to be themed after what they are now; in fact, I'd rather they weren't. The idea is to replace the Mack 10 badges with something not Mack 10, the Vilgaxia badge with something not Vilgaxia, etc. etc.

Movies
Carter's posters aren't really drawn very well, and it's hard to see what's on them since they were drawn with pencil, so they wouldn't be very good for badges anyways.

The Cyber 10 poster is literally just a bunch of Ben recolors, which I'm really trying to avoid putting on badges. The only exception is the "Gettin' Miggy With It" badge and that's only because I couldn't resist the pun. Your posters have the same problem, and as much as I love Bink, her movie pics are just photo edits.

Planets
Cranvius is already a badge. Planet X might work.

Omnitrixes
The All-Power Trix really doesn't look good, and the Multitrix is just an edit of the canon AF trix, neither of which are ideal for visual-based badges.

Heroes
Like I said at the beginning, we're trying to replace Mack 10 with something else entirely.

Pictures
That's already what I'm doing. Pdfletcher's art is good enough, but most of it isn't colored, and the ones that are colored are clearly very sloppily colored.

The Autumn of Flors Verdance is already a badge and Art Entry 2015 is, again, uncolored.

(It does looks good though. Better than your digital art by far. Have you tried sketching things out on paper and then doing digital lineart and coloring for them?)

Special Achievements
No offense to Jack or anything, but his art style always weirds me out. The proportions are never really right.

The Ultimate Ghostfreak art is neat, but has a pretty clashing color scheme and doesn't seem to have been used for anything.

Hand shake is pretty sloppily drawn and kind of a visual mess.

Noah meets noah (which is a dead link in your post btw but I found the file anyway) is probably the most decent suggestion in this category, but it's not really good by any means.

Again, thanks for the suggestions, but the only I'll probably be using is Planet X. I do sort of have a set of guidelines for what becomes a badge, which I should probably add to the Badge Project page come to think of it: There are a few exceptions to these rules, but they're fairly few and far between.
 * Badge pictures must be original art. No recolors or edits.
 * Badge art must be clear and easy to see. This means no faint lines and/or uncolored images.
 * Badge art must have relevant usage on at least one page on the wiki.
 * Badge art should be worth putting on a badge. These are rewards, after all, and the art featured on them should be of enough quality to reflect that.
 * Badge art should be from a series either currently airing or previously finished. Cancelled series and series only in production should not be on badges.